mirror_zfs/module/zfs/zpl_xattr.c

1277 lines
30 KiB
C
Raw Normal View History

/*
* CDDL HEADER START
*
* The contents of this file are subject to the terms of the
* Common Development and Distribution License (the "License").
* You may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
*
* You can obtain a copy of the license at usr/src/OPENSOLARIS.LICENSE
* or http://www.opensolaris.org/os/licensing.
* See the License for the specific language governing permissions
* and limitations under the License.
*
* When distributing Covered Code, include this CDDL HEADER in each
* file and include the License file at usr/src/OPENSOLARIS.LICENSE.
* If applicable, add the following below this CDDL HEADER, with the
* fields enclosed by brackets "[]" replaced with your own identifying
* information: Portions Copyright [yyyy] [name of copyright owner]
*
* CDDL HEADER END
*/
/*
* Copyright (c) 2011, Lawrence Livermore National Security, LLC.
*
* Extended attributes (xattr) on Solaris are implemented as files
* which exist in a hidden xattr directory. These extended attributes
* can be accessed using the attropen() system call which opens
* the extended attribute. It can then be manipulated just like
* a standard file descriptor. This has a couple advantages such
* as practically no size limit on the file, and the extended
* attributes permissions may differ from those of the parent file.
* This interface is really quite clever, but it's also completely
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
* different than what is supported on Linux. It also comes with a
* steep performance penalty when accessing small xattrs because they
* are not stored with the parent file.
*
* Under Linux extended attributes are manipulated by the system
* calls getxattr(2), setxattr(2), and listxattr(2). They consider
* extended attributes to be name/value pairs where the name is a
* NULL terminated string. The name must also include one of the
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
* following namespace prefixes:
*
* user - No restrictions and is available to user applications.
* trusted - Restricted to kernel and root (CAP_SYS_ADMIN) use.
* system - Used for access control lists (system.nfs4_acl, etc).
* security - Used by SELinux to store a files security context.
*
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
* The value under Linux to limited to 65536 bytes of binary data.
* In practice, individual xattrs tend to be much smaller than this
* and are typically less than 100 bytes. A good example of this
* are the security.selinux xattrs which are less than 100 bytes and
* exist for every file when xattr labeling is enabled.
*
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
* The Linux xattr implemenation has been written to take advantage of
* this typical usage. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set,
* then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes (SA).
* This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and
* up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional
* xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will
* be stored using the traditional directory approach.
*
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
* This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement
* when accessing xattrs because it avoids the need to perform a seek
* for every xattr value. When multiple xattrs are stored per-file
* the performance improvements are even greater because all of the
* xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached.
*
* However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port
* to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do
* enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms
* which do not support this feature.
*
* NOTE: One additional consequence of the xattr directory implementation
* is that when an extended attribute is manipulated an inode is created.
* This inode will exist in the Linux inode cache but there will be no
* associated entry in the dentry cache which references it. This is
* safe but it may result in some confusion. Enabling SA based xattrs
* largely avoids the issue except in the overflow case.
*/
#include <sys/zfs_vfsops.h>
#include <sys/zfs_vnops.h>
#include <sys/zfs_znode.h>
#include <sys/zap.h>
#include <sys/vfs.h>
#include <sys/zpl.h>
typedef struct xattr_filldir {
size_t size;
size_t offset;
char *buf;
struct inode *inode;
} xattr_filldir_t;
static int
zpl_xattr_filldir(xattr_filldir_t *xf, const char *name, int name_len)
{
if (strncmp(name, XATTR_USER_PREFIX, XATTR_USER_PREFIX_LEN) == 0)
Linux compat 2.6.39: mount_nodev() The .get_sb callback has been replaced by a .mount callback in the file_system_type structure. When using the new interface the caller must now use the mount_nodev() helper. Unfortunately, the new interface no longer passes the vfsmount down to the zfs layers. This poses a problem for the existing implementation because we currently save this pointer in the super block for latter use. It provides our only entry point in to the namespace layer for manipulating certain mount options. This needed to be done originally to allow commands like 'zfs set atime=off tank' to work properly. It also allowed me to keep more of the original Solaris code unmodified. Under Solaris there is a 1-to-1 mapping between a mount point and a file system so this is a fairly natural thing to do. However, under Linux they many be multiple entries in the namespace which reference the same filesystem. Thus keeping a back reference from the filesystem to the namespace is complicated. Rather than introduce some ugly hack to get the vfsmount and continue as before. I'm leveraging this API change to update the ZFS code to do things in a more natural way for Linux. This has the upside that is resolves the compatibility issue for the long term and fixes several other minor bugs which have been reported. This commit updates the code to remove this vfsmount back reference entirely. All modifications to filesystem mount options are now passed in to the kernel via a '-o remount'. This is the expected Linux mechanism and allows the namespace to properly handle any options which apply to it before passing them on to the file system itself. Aside from fixing the compatibility issue, removing the vfsmount has had the benefit of simplifying the code. This change which fairly involved has turned out nicely. Closes #246 Closes #217 Closes #187 Closes #248 Closes #231
2011-05-19 22:44:07 +04:00
if (!(ITOZSB(xf->inode)->z_flags & ZSB_XATTR))
return (0);
if (strncmp(name, XATTR_TRUSTED_PREFIX, XATTR_TRUSTED_PREFIX_LEN) == 0)
if (!capable(CAP_SYS_ADMIN))
return (0);
/* When xf->buf is NULL only calculate the required size. */
if (xf->buf) {
if (xf->offset + name_len + 1 > xf->size)
return (-ERANGE);
memcpy(xf->buf + xf->offset, name, name_len);
xf->buf[xf->offset + name_len] = '\0';
}
xf->offset += (name_len + 1);
return (0);
}
/*
* Read as many directory entry names as will fit in to the provided buffer,
* or when no buffer is provided calculate the required buffer size.
*/
int
zpl_xattr_readdir(struct inode *dxip, xattr_filldir_t *xf)
{
zap_cursor_t zc;
zap_attribute_t zap;
int error;
zap_cursor_init(&zc, ITOZSB(dxip)->z_os, ITOZ(dxip)->z_id);
while ((error = -zap_cursor_retrieve(&zc, &zap)) == 0) {
if (zap.za_integer_length != 8 || zap.za_num_integers != 1) {
error = -ENXIO;
break;
}
error = zpl_xattr_filldir(xf, zap.za_name, strlen(zap.za_name));
if (error)
break;
zap_cursor_advance(&zc);
}
zap_cursor_fini(&zc);
if (error == -ENOENT)
error = 0;
return (error);
}
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
static ssize_t
zpl_xattr_list_dir(xattr_filldir_t *xf, cred_t *cr)
{
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
struct inode *ip = xf->inode;
struct inode *dxip = NULL;
int error;
/* Lookup the xattr directory */
error = -zfs_lookup(ip, NULL, &dxip, LOOKUP_XATTR, cr, NULL, NULL);
if (error) {
if (error == -ENOENT)
error = 0;
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
return (error);
}
error = zpl_xattr_readdir(dxip, xf);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
iput(dxip);
return (error);
}
static ssize_t
zpl_xattr_list_sa(xattr_filldir_t *xf)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(xf->inode);
nvpair_t *nvp = NULL;
int error = 0;
mutex_enter(&zp->z_lock);
if (zp->z_xattr_cached == NULL)
error = -zfs_sa_get_xattr(zp);
mutex_exit(&zp->z_lock);
if (error)
return (error);
ASSERT(zp->z_xattr_cached);
while ((nvp = nvlist_next_nvpair(zp->z_xattr_cached, nvp)) != NULL) {
ASSERT3U(nvpair_type(nvp), ==, DATA_TYPE_BYTE_ARRAY);
error = zpl_xattr_filldir(xf, nvpair_name(nvp),
strlen(nvpair_name(nvp)));
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
if (error)
return (error);
}
return (0);
}
ssize_t
zpl_xattr_list(struct dentry *dentry, char *buffer, size_t buffer_size)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(dentry->d_inode);
zfs_sb_t *zsb = ZTOZSB(zp);
xattr_filldir_t xf = { buffer_size, 0, buffer, dentry->d_inode };
cred_t *cr = CRED();
fstrans_cookie_t cookie;
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
int error = 0;
crhold(cr);
cookie = spl_fstrans_mark();
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
rw_enter(&zp->z_xattr_lock, RW_READER);
if (zsb->z_use_sa && zp->z_is_sa) {
error = zpl_xattr_list_sa(&xf);
if (error)
goto out;
}
error = zpl_xattr_list_dir(&xf, cr);
if (error)
goto out;
error = xf.offset;
out:
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
rw_exit(&zp->z_xattr_lock);
spl_fstrans_unmark(cookie);
crfree(cr);
return (error);
}
static int
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
zpl_xattr_get_dir(struct inode *ip, const char *name, void *value,
size_t size, cred_t *cr)
{
struct inode *dxip = NULL;
struct inode *xip = NULL;
Linux AIO Support nfsd uses do_readv_writev() to implement fops->read and fops->write. do_readv_writev() will attempt to read/write using fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write, but it will fallback to fops->read and fops->write when AIO is not available. However, the fallback will perform a call for each individual data page. Since our default recordsize is 128KB, sequential operations on NFS will generate 32 DMU transactions where only 1 transaction was needed. That was unnecessary overhead and we implement fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write to eliminate it. ZFS originated in OpenSolaris, where the AIO API is entirely implemented in userland's libc by intelligently mapping them to VOP_WRITE, VOP_READ and VOP_FSYNC. Linux implements AIO inside the kernel itself. Linux filesystems therefore must implement their own AIO logic and nearly all of them implement fops->aio_write synchronously. Consequently, they do not implement aio_fsync(). However, since the ZPL works by mapping Linux's VFS calls to the functions implementing Illumos' VFS operations, we instead implement AIO in the kernel by mapping the operations to the VOP_READ, VOP_WRITE and VOP_FSYNC equivalents. We therefore implement fops->aio_fsync. One might be inclined to make our fops->aio_write implementation synchronous to make software that expects this behavior safe. However, there are several reasons not to do this: 1. Other platforms do not implement aio_write() synchronously and since the majority of userland software using AIO should be cross platform, expectations of synchronous behavior should not be a problem. 2. We would hurt the performance of programs that use POSIX interfaces properly while simultaneously encouraging the creation of more non-compliant software. 3. The broader community concluded that userland software should be patched to properly use POSIX interfaces instead of implementing hacks in filesystems to cater to broken software. This concept is best described as the O_PONIES debate. 4. Making an asynchronous write synchronous is non sequitur. Any software dependent on synchronous aio_write behavior will suffer data loss on ZFSOnLinux in a kernel panic / system failure of at most zfs_txg_timeout seconds, which by default is 5 seconds. This seems like a reasonable consequence of using non-compliant software. It should be noted that this is also a problem in the kernel itself where nfsd does not pass O_SYNC on files opened with it and instead relies on a open()/write()/close() to enforce synchronous behavior when the flush is only guarenteed on last close. Exporting any filesystem that does not implement AIO via NFS risks data loss in the event of a kernel panic / system failure when something else is also accessing the file. Exporting any file system that implements AIO the way this patch does bears similar risk. However, it seems reasonable to forgo crippling our AIO implementation in favor of developing patches to fix this problem in Linux's nfsd for the reasons stated earlier. In the interim, the risk will remain. Failing to implement AIO will not change the problem that nfsd created, so there is no reason for nfsd's mistake to block our implementation of AIO. It also should be noted that `aio_cancel()` will always return `AIO_NOTCANCELED` under this implementation. It is possible to implement aio_cancel by deferring work to taskqs and use `kiocb_set_cancel_fn()` to set a callback function for cancelling work sent to taskqs, but the simpler approach is allowed by the specification: ``` Which operations are cancelable is implementation-defined. ``` http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009695399/functions/aio_cancel.html The only programs on my system that are capable of using `aio_cancel()` are QEMU, beecrypt and fio use it according to a recursive grep of my system's `/usr/src/debug`. That suggests that `aio_cancel()` users are rare. Implementing aio_cancel() is left to a future date when it is clear that there are consumers that benefit from its implementation to justify the work. Lastly, it is important to know that handling of the iovec updates differs between Illumos and Linux in the implementation of read/write. On Linux, it is the VFS' responsibility whle on Illumos, it is the filesystem's responsibility. We take the intermediate solution of copying the iovec so that the ZFS code can update it like on Solaris while leaving the originals alone. This imposes some overhead. We could always revisit this should profiling show that the allocations are a problem. Signed-off-by: Richard Yao <ryao@gentoo.org> Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Closes #223 Closes #2373
2014-08-04 15:09:32 +04:00
loff_t pos = 0;
int error;
/* Lookup the xattr directory */
error = -zfs_lookup(ip, NULL, &dxip, LOOKUP_XATTR, cr, NULL, NULL);
if (error)
goto out;
/* Lookup a specific xattr name in the directory */
error = -zfs_lookup(dxip, (char *)name, &xip, 0, cr, NULL, NULL);
if (error)
goto out;
if (!size) {
error = i_size_read(xip);
goto out;
}
if (size < i_size_read(xip)) {
error = -ERANGE;
goto out;
}
Linux AIO Support nfsd uses do_readv_writev() to implement fops->read and fops->write. do_readv_writev() will attempt to read/write using fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write, but it will fallback to fops->read and fops->write when AIO is not available. However, the fallback will perform a call for each individual data page. Since our default recordsize is 128KB, sequential operations on NFS will generate 32 DMU transactions where only 1 transaction was needed. That was unnecessary overhead and we implement fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write to eliminate it. ZFS originated in OpenSolaris, where the AIO API is entirely implemented in userland's libc by intelligently mapping them to VOP_WRITE, VOP_READ and VOP_FSYNC. Linux implements AIO inside the kernel itself. Linux filesystems therefore must implement their own AIO logic and nearly all of them implement fops->aio_write synchronously. Consequently, they do not implement aio_fsync(). However, since the ZPL works by mapping Linux's VFS calls to the functions implementing Illumos' VFS operations, we instead implement AIO in the kernel by mapping the operations to the VOP_READ, VOP_WRITE and VOP_FSYNC equivalents. We therefore implement fops->aio_fsync. One might be inclined to make our fops->aio_write implementation synchronous to make software that expects this behavior safe. However, there are several reasons not to do this: 1. Other platforms do not implement aio_write() synchronously and since the majority of userland software using AIO should be cross platform, expectations of synchronous behavior should not be a problem. 2. We would hurt the performance of programs that use POSIX interfaces properly while simultaneously encouraging the creation of more non-compliant software. 3. The broader community concluded that userland software should be patched to properly use POSIX interfaces instead of implementing hacks in filesystems to cater to broken software. This concept is best described as the O_PONIES debate. 4. Making an asynchronous write synchronous is non sequitur. Any software dependent on synchronous aio_write behavior will suffer data loss on ZFSOnLinux in a kernel panic / system failure of at most zfs_txg_timeout seconds, which by default is 5 seconds. This seems like a reasonable consequence of using non-compliant software. It should be noted that this is also a problem in the kernel itself where nfsd does not pass O_SYNC on files opened with it and instead relies on a open()/write()/close() to enforce synchronous behavior when the flush is only guarenteed on last close. Exporting any filesystem that does not implement AIO via NFS risks data loss in the event of a kernel panic / system failure when something else is also accessing the file. Exporting any file system that implements AIO the way this patch does bears similar risk. However, it seems reasonable to forgo crippling our AIO implementation in favor of developing patches to fix this problem in Linux's nfsd for the reasons stated earlier. In the interim, the risk will remain. Failing to implement AIO will not change the problem that nfsd created, so there is no reason for nfsd's mistake to block our implementation of AIO. It also should be noted that `aio_cancel()` will always return `AIO_NOTCANCELED` under this implementation. It is possible to implement aio_cancel by deferring work to taskqs and use `kiocb_set_cancel_fn()` to set a callback function for cancelling work sent to taskqs, but the simpler approach is allowed by the specification: ``` Which operations are cancelable is implementation-defined. ``` http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009695399/functions/aio_cancel.html The only programs on my system that are capable of using `aio_cancel()` are QEMU, beecrypt and fio use it according to a recursive grep of my system's `/usr/src/debug`. That suggests that `aio_cancel()` users are rare. Implementing aio_cancel() is left to a future date when it is clear that there are consumers that benefit from its implementation to justify the work. Lastly, it is important to know that handling of the iovec updates differs between Illumos and Linux in the implementation of read/write. On Linux, it is the VFS' responsibility whle on Illumos, it is the filesystem's responsibility. We take the intermediate solution of copying the iovec so that the ZFS code can update it like on Solaris while leaving the originals alone. This imposes some overhead. We could always revisit this should profiling show that the allocations are a problem. Signed-off-by: Richard Yao <ryao@gentoo.org> Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Closes #223 Closes #2373
2014-08-04 15:09:32 +04:00
error = zpl_read_common(xip, value, size, &pos, UIO_SYSSPACE, 0, cr);
out:
if (xip)
iput(xip);
if (dxip)
iput(dxip);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
return (error);
}
static int
zpl_xattr_get_sa(struct inode *ip, const char *name, void *value, size_t size)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(ip);
uchar_t *nv_value;
uint_t nv_size;
int error = 0;
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
ASSERT(RW_LOCK_HELD(&zp->z_xattr_lock));
mutex_enter(&zp->z_lock);
if (zp->z_xattr_cached == NULL)
error = -zfs_sa_get_xattr(zp);
mutex_exit(&zp->z_lock);
if (error)
return (error);
ASSERT(zp->z_xattr_cached);
error = -nvlist_lookup_byte_array(zp->z_xattr_cached, name,
&nv_value, &nv_size);
if (error)
return (error);
if (!size)
return (nv_size);
if (size < nv_size)
return (-ERANGE);
memcpy(value, nv_value, nv_size);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
return (nv_size);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
}
static int
__zpl_xattr_get(struct inode *ip, const char *name, void *value, size_t size,
cred_t *cr)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(ip);
zfs_sb_t *zsb = ZTOZSB(zp);
int error;
ASSERT(RW_LOCK_HELD(&zp->z_xattr_lock));
if (zsb->z_use_sa && zp->z_is_sa) {
error = zpl_xattr_get_sa(ip, name, value, size);
if (error != -ENOENT)
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
goto out;
}
error = zpl_xattr_get_dir(ip, name, value, size, cr);
out:
if (error == -ENOENT)
error = -ENODATA;
return (error);
}
static int
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
zpl_xattr_get(struct inode *ip, const char *name, void *value, size_t size)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(ip);
cred_t *cr = CRED();
fstrans_cookie_t cookie;
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
int error;
crhold(cr);
cookie = spl_fstrans_mark();
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
rw_enter(&zp->z_xattr_lock, RW_READER);
error = __zpl_xattr_get(ip, name, value, size, cr);
rw_exit(&zp->z_xattr_lock);
spl_fstrans_unmark(cookie);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
crfree(cr);
return (error);
}
static int
zpl_xattr_set_dir(struct inode *ip, const char *name, const void *value,
size_t size, int flags, cred_t *cr)
{
struct inode *dxip = NULL;
struct inode *xip = NULL;
vattr_t *vap = NULL;
ssize_t wrote;
int lookup_flags, error;
const int xattr_mode = S_IFREG | 0644;
Linux AIO Support nfsd uses do_readv_writev() to implement fops->read and fops->write. do_readv_writev() will attempt to read/write using fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write, but it will fallback to fops->read and fops->write when AIO is not available. However, the fallback will perform a call for each individual data page. Since our default recordsize is 128KB, sequential operations on NFS will generate 32 DMU transactions where only 1 transaction was needed. That was unnecessary overhead and we implement fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write to eliminate it. ZFS originated in OpenSolaris, where the AIO API is entirely implemented in userland's libc by intelligently mapping them to VOP_WRITE, VOP_READ and VOP_FSYNC. Linux implements AIO inside the kernel itself. Linux filesystems therefore must implement their own AIO logic and nearly all of them implement fops->aio_write synchronously. Consequently, they do not implement aio_fsync(). However, since the ZPL works by mapping Linux's VFS calls to the functions implementing Illumos' VFS operations, we instead implement AIO in the kernel by mapping the operations to the VOP_READ, VOP_WRITE and VOP_FSYNC equivalents. We therefore implement fops->aio_fsync. One might be inclined to make our fops->aio_write implementation synchronous to make software that expects this behavior safe. However, there are several reasons not to do this: 1. Other platforms do not implement aio_write() synchronously and since the majority of userland software using AIO should be cross platform, expectations of synchronous behavior should not be a problem. 2. We would hurt the performance of programs that use POSIX interfaces properly while simultaneously encouraging the creation of more non-compliant software. 3. The broader community concluded that userland software should be patched to properly use POSIX interfaces instead of implementing hacks in filesystems to cater to broken software. This concept is best described as the O_PONIES debate. 4. Making an asynchronous write synchronous is non sequitur. Any software dependent on synchronous aio_write behavior will suffer data loss on ZFSOnLinux in a kernel panic / system failure of at most zfs_txg_timeout seconds, which by default is 5 seconds. This seems like a reasonable consequence of using non-compliant software. It should be noted that this is also a problem in the kernel itself where nfsd does not pass O_SYNC on files opened with it and instead relies on a open()/write()/close() to enforce synchronous behavior when the flush is only guarenteed on last close. Exporting any filesystem that does not implement AIO via NFS risks data loss in the event of a kernel panic / system failure when something else is also accessing the file. Exporting any file system that implements AIO the way this patch does bears similar risk. However, it seems reasonable to forgo crippling our AIO implementation in favor of developing patches to fix this problem in Linux's nfsd for the reasons stated earlier. In the interim, the risk will remain. Failing to implement AIO will not change the problem that nfsd created, so there is no reason for nfsd's mistake to block our implementation of AIO. It also should be noted that `aio_cancel()` will always return `AIO_NOTCANCELED` under this implementation. It is possible to implement aio_cancel by deferring work to taskqs and use `kiocb_set_cancel_fn()` to set a callback function for cancelling work sent to taskqs, but the simpler approach is allowed by the specification: ``` Which operations are cancelable is implementation-defined. ``` http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009695399/functions/aio_cancel.html The only programs on my system that are capable of using `aio_cancel()` are QEMU, beecrypt and fio use it according to a recursive grep of my system's `/usr/src/debug`. That suggests that `aio_cancel()` users are rare. Implementing aio_cancel() is left to a future date when it is clear that there are consumers that benefit from its implementation to justify the work. Lastly, it is important to know that handling of the iovec updates differs between Illumos and Linux in the implementation of read/write. On Linux, it is the VFS' responsibility whle on Illumos, it is the filesystem's responsibility. We take the intermediate solution of copying the iovec so that the ZFS code can update it like on Solaris while leaving the originals alone. This imposes some overhead. We could always revisit this should profiling show that the allocations are a problem. Signed-off-by: Richard Yao <ryao@gentoo.org> Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Closes #223 Closes #2373
2014-08-04 15:09:32 +04:00
loff_t pos = 0;
/*
* Lookup the xattr directory. When we're adding an entry pass
* CREATE_XATTR_DIR to ensure the xattr directory is created.
* When removing an entry this flag is not passed to avoid
* unnecessarily creating a new xattr directory.
*/
lookup_flags = LOOKUP_XATTR;
if (value != NULL)
lookup_flags |= CREATE_XATTR_DIR;
error = -zfs_lookup(ip, NULL, &dxip, lookup_flags, cr, NULL, NULL);
if (error)
goto out;
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
/* Lookup a specific xattr name in the directory */
error = -zfs_lookup(dxip, (char *)name, &xip, 0, cr, NULL, NULL);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
if (error && (error != -ENOENT))
goto out;
error = 0;
/* Remove a specific name xattr when value is set to NULL. */
if (value == NULL) {
if (xip)
error = -zfs_remove(dxip, (char *)name, cr);
goto out;
}
/* Lookup failed create a new xattr. */
if (xip == NULL) {
vap = kmem_zalloc(sizeof (vattr_t), KM_SLEEP);
vap->va_mode = xattr_mode;
vap->va_mask = ATTR_MODE;
vap->va_uid = crgetfsuid(cr);
vap->va_gid = crgetfsgid(cr);
error = -zfs_create(dxip, (char *)name, vap, 0, 0644, &xip,
cr, 0, NULL);
if (error)
goto out;
}
ASSERT(xip != NULL);
error = -zfs_freesp(ITOZ(xip), 0, 0, xattr_mode, TRUE);
if (error)
goto out;
Linux AIO Support nfsd uses do_readv_writev() to implement fops->read and fops->write. do_readv_writev() will attempt to read/write using fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write, but it will fallback to fops->read and fops->write when AIO is not available. However, the fallback will perform a call for each individual data page. Since our default recordsize is 128KB, sequential operations on NFS will generate 32 DMU transactions where only 1 transaction was needed. That was unnecessary overhead and we implement fops->aio_read and fops->aio_write to eliminate it. ZFS originated in OpenSolaris, where the AIO API is entirely implemented in userland's libc by intelligently mapping them to VOP_WRITE, VOP_READ and VOP_FSYNC. Linux implements AIO inside the kernel itself. Linux filesystems therefore must implement their own AIO logic and nearly all of them implement fops->aio_write synchronously. Consequently, they do not implement aio_fsync(). However, since the ZPL works by mapping Linux's VFS calls to the functions implementing Illumos' VFS operations, we instead implement AIO in the kernel by mapping the operations to the VOP_READ, VOP_WRITE and VOP_FSYNC equivalents. We therefore implement fops->aio_fsync. One might be inclined to make our fops->aio_write implementation synchronous to make software that expects this behavior safe. However, there are several reasons not to do this: 1. Other platforms do not implement aio_write() synchronously and since the majority of userland software using AIO should be cross platform, expectations of synchronous behavior should not be a problem. 2. We would hurt the performance of programs that use POSIX interfaces properly while simultaneously encouraging the creation of more non-compliant software. 3. The broader community concluded that userland software should be patched to properly use POSIX interfaces instead of implementing hacks in filesystems to cater to broken software. This concept is best described as the O_PONIES debate. 4. Making an asynchronous write synchronous is non sequitur. Any software dependent on synchronous aio_write behavior will suffer data loss on ZFSOnLinux in a kernel panic / system failure of at most zfs_txg_timeout seconds, which by default is 5 seconds. This seems like a reasonable consequence of using non-compliant software. It should be noted that this is also a problem in the kernel itself where nfsd does not pass O_SYNC on files opened with it and instead relies on a open()/write()/close() to enforce synchronous behavior when the flush is only guarenteed on last close. Exporting any filesystem that does not implement AIO via NFS risks data loss in the event of a kernel panic / system failure when something else is also accessing the file. Exporting any file system that implements AIO the way this patch does bears similar risk. However, it seems reasonable to forgo crippling our AIO implementation in favor of developing patches to fix this problem in Linux's nfsd for the reasons stated earlier. In the interim, the risk will remain. Failing to implement AIO will not change the problem that nfsd created, so there is no reason for nfsd's mistake to block our implementation of AIO. It also should be noted that `aio_cancel()` will always return `AIO_NOTCANCELED` under this implementation. It is possible to implement aio_cancel by deferring work to taskqs and use `kiocb_set_cancel_fn()` to set a callback function for cancelling work sent to taskqs, but the simpler approach is allowed by the specification: ``` Which operations are cancelable is implementation-defined. ``` http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009695399/functions/aio_cancel.html The only programs on my system that are capable of using `aio_cancel()` are QEMU, beecrypt and fio use it according to a recursive grep of my system's `/usr/src/debug`. That suggests that `aio_cancel()` users are rare. Implementing aio_cancel() is left to a future date when it is clear that there are consumers that benefit from its implementation to justify the work. Lastly, it is important to know that handling of the iovec updates differs between Illumos and Linux in the implementation of read/write. On Linux, it is the VFS' responsibility whle on Illumos, it is the filesystem's responsibility. We take the intermediate solution of copying the iovec so that the ZFS code can update it like on Solaris while leaving the originals alone. This imposes some overhead. We could always revisit this should profiling show that the allocations are a problem. Signed-off-by: Richard Yao <ryao@gentoo.org> Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Closes #223 Closes #2373
2014-08-04 15:09:32 +04:00
wrote = zpl_write_common(xip, value, size, &pos, UIO_SYSSPACE, 0, cr);
if (wrote < 0)
error = wrote;
out:
if (vap)
kmem_free(vap, sizeof (vattr_t));
if (xip)
iput(xip);
if (dxip)
iput(dxip);
if (error == -ENOENT)
error = -ENODATA;
ASSERT3S(error, <=, 0);
return (error);
}
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
static int
zpl_xattr_set_sa(struct inode *ip, const char *name, const void *value,
size_t size, int flags, cred_t *cr)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(ip);
nvlist_t *nvl;
size_t sa_size;
int error;
ASSERT(zp->z_xattr_cached);
nvl = zp->z_xattr_cached;
if (value == NULL) {
error = -nvlist_remove(nvl, name, DATA_TYPE_BYTE_ARRAY);
if (error == -ENOENT)
error = zpl_xattr_set_dir(ip, name, NULL, 0, flags, cr);
} else {
/* Limited to 32k to keep nvpair memory allocations small */
if (size > DXATTR_MAX_ENTRY_SIZE)
return (-EFBIG);
/* Prevent the DXATTR SA from consuming the entire SA region */
error = -nvlist_size(nvl, &sa_size, NV_ENCODE_XDR);
if (error)
return (error);
if (sa_size > DXATTR_MAX_SA_SIZE)
return (-EFBIG);
error = -nvlist_add_byte_array(nvl, name,
(uchar_t *)value, size);
if (error)
return (error);
}
/* Update the SA for additions, modifications, and removals. */
if (!error)
error = -zfs_sa_set_xattr(zp);
ASSERT3S(error, <=, 0);
return (error);
}
static int
zpl_xattr_set(struct inode *ip, const char *name, const void *value,
size_t size, int flags)
{
znode_t *zp = ITOZ(ip);
zfs_sb_t *zsb = ZTOZSB(zp);
cred_t *cr = CRED();
fstrans_cookie_t cookie;
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
int error;
crhold(cr);
cookie = spl_fstrans_mark();
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
rw_enter(&ITOZ(ip)->z_xattr_lock, RW_WRITER);
/*
* Before setting the xattr check to see if it already exists.
* This is done to ensure the following optional flags are honored.
*
* XATTR_CREATE: fail if xattr already exists
* XATTR_REPLACE: fail if xattr does not exist
*/
error = __zpl_xattr_get(ip, name, NULL, 0, cr);
if (error < 0) {
if (error != -ENODATA)
goto out;
if (flags & XATTR_REPLACE)
goto out;
/* The xattr to be removed already doesn't exist */
error = 0;
if (value == NULL)
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
goto out;
} else {
error = -EEXIST;
if (flags & XATTR_CREATE)
goto out;
}
/* Preferentially store the xattr as a SA for better performance */
if (zsb->z_use_sa && zsb->z_xattr_sa && zp->z_is_sa) {
error = zpl_xattr_set_sa(ip, name, value, size, flags, cr);
if (error == 0)
goto out;
}
error = zpl_xattr_set_dir(ip, name, value, size, flags, cr);
out:
rw_exit(&ITOZ(ip)->z_xattr_lock);
spl_fstrans_unmark(cookie);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
crfree(cr);
ASSERT3S(error, <=, 0);
return (error);
}
static int
__zpl_xattr_user_get(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
void *value, size_t size)
{
char *xattr_name;
int error;
if (strcmp(name, "") == 0)
return (-EINVAL);
Linux compat 2.6.39: mount_nodev() The .get_sb callback has been replaced by a .mount callback in the file_system_type structure. When using the new interface the caller must now use the mount_nodev() helper. Unfortunately, the new interface no longer passes the vfsmount down to the zfs layers. This poses a problem for the existing implementation because we currently save this pointer in the super block for latter use. It provides our only entry point in to the namespace layer for manipulating certain mount options. This needed to be done originally to allow commands like 'zfs set atime=off tank' to work properly. It also allowed me to keep more of the original Solaris code unmodified. Under Solaris there is a 1-to-1 mapping between a mount point and a file system so this is a fairly natural thing to do. However, under Linux they many be multiple entries in the namespace which reference the same filesystem. Thus keeping a back reference from the filesystem to the namespace is complicated. Rather than introduce some ugly hack to get the vfsmount and continue as before. I'm leveraging this API change to update the ZFS code to do things in a more natural way for Linux. This has the upside that is resolves the compatibility issue for the long term and fixes several other minor bugs which have been reported. This commit updates the code to remove this vfsmount back reference entirely. All modifications to filesystem mount options are now passed in to the kernel via a '-o remount'. This is the expected Linux mechanism and allows the namespace to properly handle any options which apply to it before passing them on to the file system itself. Aside from fixing the compatibility issue, removing the vfsmount has had the benefit of simplifying the code. This change which fairly involved has turned out nicely. Closes #246 Closes #217 Closes #187 Closes #248 Closes #231
2011-05-19 22:44:07 +04:00
if (!(ITOZSB(ip)->z_flags & ZSB_XATTR))
return (-EOPNOTSUPP);
xattr_name = kmem_asprintf("%s%s", XATTR_USER_PREFIX, name);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
error = zpl_xattr_get(ip, xattr_name, value, size);
strfree(xattr_name);
return (error);
}
ZPL_XATTR_GET_WRAPPER(zpl_xattr_user_get);
static int
__zpl_xattr_user_set(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags)
{
char *xattr_name;
int error;
if (strcmp(name, "") == 0)
return (-EINVAL);
Linux compat 2.6.39: mount_nodev() The .get_sb callback has been replaced by a .mount callback in the file_system_type structure. When using the new interface the caller must now use the mount_nodev() helper. Unfortunately, the new interface no longer passes the vfsmount down to the zfs layers. This poses a problem for the existing implementation because we currently save this pointer in the super block for latter use. It provides our only entry point in to the namespace layer for manipulating certain mount options. This needed to be done originally to allow commands like 'zfs set atime=off tank' to work properly. It also allowed me to keep more of the original Solaris code unmodified. Under Solaris there is a 1-to-1 mapping between a mount point and a file system so this is a fairly natural thing to do. However, under Linux they many be multiple entries in the namespace which reference the same filesystem. Thus keeping a back reference from the filesystem to the namespace is complicated. Rather than introduce some ugly hack to get the vfsmount and continue as before. I'm leveraging this API change to update the ZFS code to do things in a more natural way for Linux. This has the upside that is resolves the compatibility issue for the long term and fixes several other minor bugs which have been reported. This commit updates the code to remove this vfsmount back reference entirely. All modifications to filesystem mount options are now passed in to the kernel via a '-o remount'. This is the expected Linux mechanism and allows the namespace to properly handle any options which apply to it before passing them on to the file system itself. Aside from fixing the compatibility issue, removing the vfsmount has had the benefit of simplifying the code. This change which fairly involved has turned out nicely. Closes #246 Closes #217 Closes #187 Closes #248 Closes #231
2011-05-19 22:44:07 +04:00
if (!(ITOZSB(ip)->z_flags & ZSB_XATTR))
return (-EOPNOTSUPP);
xattr_name = kmem_asprintf("%s%s", XATTR_USER_PREFIX, name);
error = zpl_xattr_set(ip, xattr_name, value, size, flags);
strfree(xattr_name);
return (error);
}
ZPL_XATTR_SET_WRAPPER(zpl_xattr_user_set);
xattr_handler_t zpl_xattr_user_handler = {
.prefix = XATTR_USER_PREFIX,
.get = zpl_xattr_user_get,
.set = zpl_xattr_user_set,
};
static int
__zpl_xattr_trusted_get(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
void *value, size_t size)
{
char *xattr_name;
int error;
if (!capable(CAP_SYS_ADMIN))
return (-EACCES);
if (strcmp(name, "") == 0)
return (-EINVAL);
xattr_name = kmem_asprintf("%s%s", XATTR_TRUSTED_PREFIX, name);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
error = zpl_xattr_get(ip, xattr_name, value, size);
strfree(xattr_name);
return (error);
}
ZPL_XATTR_GET_WRAPPER(zpl_xattr_trusted_get);
static int
__zpl_xattr_trusted_set(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags)
{
char *xattr_name;
int error;
if (!capable(CAP_SYS_ADMIN))
return (-EACCES);
if (strcmp(name, "") == 0)
return (-EINVAL);
xattr_name = kmem_asprintf("%s%s", XATTR_TRUSTED_PREFIX, name);
error = zpl_xattr_set(ip, xattr_name, value, size, flags);
strfree(xattr_name);
return (error);
}
ZPL_XATTR_SET_WRAPPER(zpl_xattr_trusted_set);
xattr_handler_t zpl_xattr_trusted_handler = {
.prefix = XATTR_TRUSTED_PREFIX,
.get = zpl_xattr_trusted_get,
.set = zpl_xattr_trusted_set,
};
static int
__zpl_xattr_security_get(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
void *value, size_t size)
{
char *xattr_name;
int error;
if (strcmp(name, "") == 0)
return (-EINVAL);
xattr_name = kmem_asprintf("%s%s", XATTR_SECURITY_PREFIX, name);
Implement SA based xattrs The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden directory. In this directory a file name represents the xattr name and the file contexts are the xattr binary data. This approach is very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs. However, it also suffers from a significant performance penalty. Accessing a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks. 1) Lookup the dnode object. 2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object. 3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory. To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3 and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk. When the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external block is allocated for them. In practice most xattrs are small and this approach works well. The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean way to make this optimization. When the dataset property 'xattr=sa' is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes. This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block. If additional xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be stored using the traditional directory approach. This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4 and xfs (see table below). When multiple xattrs are stored per-file the performance improvements are even greater because all of the xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached. However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port to maximize compatibility with other implementations. If you do enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms which do not support this feature. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ | setxattr | getxattr bytes | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa | ext4 xfs zfs-dir zfs-sa ------+--------------------------------+------------------------------ 1 | 2.33 31.88 21.50 4.57 | 2.35 2.64 6.29 2.43 32 | 2.79 30.68 21.98 4.60 | 2.44 2.59 6.78 2.48 256 | 3.25 31.99 21.36 5.92 | 2.32 2.71 6.22 3.14 1024 | 3.30 32.61 22.83 8.45 | 2.40 2.79 6.24 3.27 4096 | 3.57 317.46 22.52 10.73 | 2.78 28.62 6.90 3.94 16384 | n/a 2342.39 34.30 19.20 | n/a 45.44 145.90 7.55 65536 | n/a 2941.39 128.15 131.32* | n/a 141.92 256.85 262.12* Legend: * ext4 - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'. * xfs - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options. * zfs-dir - Directory based xattrs only. * zfs-sa - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured. NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file. NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes. NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache. NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive. Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov> Issue #443
2011-10-25 03:55:20 +04:00
error = zpl_xattr_get(ip, xattr_name, value, size);
strfree(xattr_name);
return (error);
}
ZPL_XATTR_GET_WRAPPER(zpl_xattr_security_get);
static int
__zpl_xattr_security_set(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags)
{
char *xattr_name;
int error;
if (strcmp(name, "") == 0)
return (-EINVAL);
xattr_name = kmem_asprintf("%s%s", XATTR_SECURITY_PREFIX, name);
error = zpl_xattr_set(ip, xattr_name, value, size, flags);
strfree(xattr_name);
return (error);
}
ZPL_XATTR_SET_WRAPPER(zpl_xattr_security_set);
#ifdef HAVE_CALLBACK_SECURITY_INODE_INIT_SECURITY
static int
__zpl_xattr_security_init(struct inode *ip, const struct xattr *xattrs,
void *fs_info)
{
const struct xattr *xattr;
int error = 0;
for (xattr = xattrs; xattr->name != NULL; xattr++) {
error = __zpl_xattr_security_set(ip,
xattr->name, xattr->value, xattr->value_len, 0);
if (error < 0)
break;
}
return (error);
}
int
zpl_xattr_security_init(struct inode *ip, struct inode *dip,
const struct qstr *qstr)
{
return security_inode_init_security(ip, dip, qstr,
&__zpl_xattr_security_init, NULL);
}
#else
int
zpl_xattr_security_init(struct inode *ip, struct inode *dip,
const struct qstr *qstr)
{
int error;
size_t len;
void *value;
char *name;
error = zpl_security_inode_init_security(ip, dip, qstr,
&name, &value, &len);
if (error) {
if (error == -EOPNOTSUPP)
return (0);
return (error);
}
error = __zpl_xattr_security_set(ip, name, value, len, 0);
kfree(name);
kfree(value);
return (error);
}
#endif /* HAVE_CALLBACK_SECURITY_INODE_INIT_SECURITY */
xattr_handler_t zpl_xattr_security_handler = {
.prefix = XATTR_SECURITY_PREFIX,
.get = zpl_xattr_security_get,
.set = zpl_xattr_security_set,
};
#ifdef CONFIG_FS_POSIX_ACL
int
zpl_set_acl(struct inode *ip, int type, struct posix_acl *acl)
{
struct super_block *sb = ITOZSB(ip)->z_sb;
char *name, *value = NULL;
int error = 0;
size_t size = 0;
if (S_ISLNK(ip->i_mode))
return (-EOPNOTSUPP);
switch (type) {
case ACL_TYPE_ACCESS:
name = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_ACCESS;
if (acl) {
zpl_equivmode_t mode = ip->i_mode;
error = posix_acl_equiv_mode(acl, &mode);
if (error < 0) {
return (error);
} else {
/*
* The mode bits will have been set by
* ->zfs_setattr()->zfs_acl_chmod_setattr()
* using the ZFS ACL conversion. If they
* differ from the Posix ACL conversion dirty
* the inode to write the Posix mode bits.
*/
if (ip->i_mode != mode) {
ip->i_mode = mode;
ip->i_ctime = current_fs_time(sb);
zfs_mark_inode_dirty(ip);
}
if (error == 0)
acl = NULL;
}
}
break;
case ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT:
name = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_DEFAULT;
if (!S_ISDIR(ip->i_mode))
return (acl ? -EACCES : 0);
break;
default:
return (-EINVAL);
}
if (acl) {
size = posix_acl_xattr_size(acl->a_count);
value = kmem_alloc(size, KM_SLEEP);
error = zpl_acl_to_xattr(acl, value, size);
if (error < 0) {
kmem_free(value, size);
return (error);
}
}
error = zpl_xattr_set(ip, name, value, size, 0);
if (value)
kmem_free(value, size);
if (!error) {
if (acl)
zpl_set_cached_acl(ip, type, acl);
else
zpl_forget_cached_acl(ip, type);
}
return (error);
}
struct posix_acl *
zpl_get_acl(struct inode *ip, int type)
{
struct posix_acl *acl;
void *value = NULL;
char *name;
int size;
#ifdef HAVE_POSIX_ACL_CACHING
acl = get_cached_acl(ip, type);
if (acl != ACL_NOT_CACHED)
return (acl);
#endif /* HAVE_POSIX_ACL_CACHING */
switch (type) {
case ACL_TYPE_ACCESS:
name = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_ACCESS;
break;
case ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT:
name = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_DEFAULT;
break;
default:
return (ERR_PTR(-EINVAL));
}
size = zpl_xattr_get(ip, name, NULL, 0);
if (size > 0) {
value = kmem_alloc(size, KM_SLEEP);
size = zpl_xattr_get(ip, name, value, size);
}
if (size > 0) {
acl = zpl_acl_from_xattr(value, size);
} else if (size == -ENODATA || size == -ENOSYS) {
acl = NULL;
} else {
acl = ERR_PTR(-EIO);
}
if (size > 0)
kmem_free(value, size);
if (!IS_ERR(acl))
zpl_set_cached_acl(ip, type, acl);
return (acl);
}
#if !defined(HAVE_GET_ACL)
static int
__zpl_check_acl(struct inode *ip, int mask)
{
struct posix_acl *acl;
int error;
acl = zpl_get_acl(ip, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
if (IS_ERR(acl))
return (PTR_ERR(acl));
if (acl) {
error = posix_acl_permission(ip, acl, mask);
zpl_posix_acl_release(acl);
return (error);
}
return (-EAGAIN);
}
#if defined(HAVE_CHECK_ACL_WITH_FLAGS)
int
zpl_check_acl(struct inode *ip, int mask, unsigned int flags)
{
return (__zpl_check_acl(ip, mask));
}
#elif defined(HAVE_CHECK_ACL)
int
zpl_check_acl(struct inode *ip, int mask)
{
return (__zpl_check_acl(ip, mask));
}
#elif defined(HAVE_PERMISSION_WITH_NAMEIDATA)
int
zpl_permission(struct inode *ip, int mask, struct nameidata *nd)
{
return (generic_permission(ip, mask, __zpl_check_acl));
}
#elif defined(HAVE_PERMISSION)
int
zpl_permission(struct inode *ip, int mask)
{
return (generic_permission(ip, mask, __zpl_check_acl));
}
#endif /* HAVE_CHECK_ACL | HAVE_PERMISSION */
#endif /* !HAVE_GET_ACL */
int
zpl_init_acl(struct inode *ip, struct inode *dir)
{
struct posix_acl *acl = NULL;
int error = 0;
if (ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type != ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL)
return (0);
if (!S_ISLNK(ip->i_mode)) {
if (ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type == ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL) {
acl = zpl_get_acl(dir, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
if (IS_ERR(acl))
return (PTR_ERR(acl));
}
if (!acl) {
ip->i_mode &= ~current_umask();
ip->i_ctime = current_fs_time(ITOZSB(ip)->z_sb);
zfs_mark_inode_dirty(ip);
return (0);
}
}
if ((ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type == ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL) && acl) {
umode_t mode;
if (S_ISDIR(ip->i_mode)) {
error = zpl_set_acl(ip, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT, acl);
if (error)
goto out;
}
mode = ip->i_mode;
error = __posix_acl_create(&acl, GFP_KERNEL, &mode);
if (error >= 0) {
ip->i_mode = mode;
zfs_mark_inode_dirty(ip);
if (error > 0)
error = zpl_set_acl(ip, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS, acl);
}
}
out:
zpl_posix_acl_release(acl);
return (error);
}
int
zpl_chmod_acl(struct inode *ip)
{
struct posix_acl *acl;
int error;
if (ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type != ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL)
return (0);
if (S_ISLNK(ip->i_mode))
return (-EOPNOTSUPP);
acl = zpl_get_acl(ip, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
if (IS_ERR(acl) || !acl)
return (PTR_ERR(acl));
error = __posix_acl_chmod(&acl, GFP_KERNEL, ip->i_mode);
if (!error)
error = zpl_set_acl(ip, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS, acl);
zpl_posix_acl_release(acl);
return (error);
}
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list(struct inode *ip, char *list, size_t list_size,
const char *name, size_t name_len, int type)
{
char *xattr_name;
size_t xattr_size;
if (ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type != ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL)
return (0);
switch (type) {
case ACL_TYPE_ACCESS:
xattr_name = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_ACCESS;
xattr_size = sizeof (xattr_name);
break;
case ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT:
xattr_name = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_DEFAULT;
xattr_size = sizeof (xattr_name);
break;
default:
return (0);
}
if (list && xattr_size <= list_size)
memcpy(list, xattr_name, xattr_size);
return (xattr_size);
}
#ifdef HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_LIST
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list_access(struct dentry *dentry, char *list,
size_t list_size, const char *name, size_t name_len, int type)
{
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
return zpl_xattr_acl_list(dentry->d_inode,
list, list_size, name, name_len, type);
}
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list_default(struct dentry *dentry, char *list,
size_t list_size, const char *name, size_t name_len, int type)
{
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
return zpl_xattr_acl_list(dentry->d_inode,
list, list_size, name, name_len, type);
}
#elif defined(HAVE_HANDLER_XATTR_LIST)
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list_access(const struct xattr_handler *handler,
struct dentry *dentry, char *list, size_t list_size, const char *name,
size_t name_len)
{
int type = handler->flags;
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
return zpl_xattr_acl_list(dentry->d_inode,
list, list_size, name, name_len, type);
}
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list_default(const struct xattr_handler *handler,
struct dentry *dentry, char *list, size_t list_size, const char *name,
size_t name_len)
{
int type = handler->flags;
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
return zpl_xattr_acl_list(dentry->d_inode,
list, list_size, name, name_len, type);
}
#else
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list_access(struct inode *ip, char *list, size_t list_size,
const char *name, size_t name_len)
{
return zpl_xattr_acl_list(ip,
list, list_size, name, name_len, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
}
static size_t
zpl_xattr_acl_list_default(struct inode *ip, char *list, size_t list_size,
const char *name, size_t name_len)
{
return zpl_xattr_acl_list(ip,
list, list_size, name, name_len, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
}
#endif /* HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_LIST */
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
void *buffer, size_t size, int type)
{
struct posix_acl *acl;
int error;
if (strcmp(name, "") != 0)
return (-EINVAL);
if (ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type != ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL)
return (-EOPNOTSUPP);
acl = zpl_get_acl(ip, type);
if (IS_ERR(acl))
return (PTR_ERR(acl));
if (acl == NULL)
return (-ENODATA);
error = zpl_acl_to_xattr(acl, buffer, size);
zpl_posix_acl_release(acl);
return (error);
}
#ifdef HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_GET
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get_access(struct dentry *dentry, const char *name,
void *buffer, size_t size, int type)
{
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
return (zpl_xattr_acl_get(dentry->d_inode, name, buffer, size, type));
}
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get_default(struct dentry *dentry, const char *name,
void *buffer, size_t size, int type)
{
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
return (zpl_xattr_acl_get(dentry->d_inode, name, buffer, size, type));
}
#elif defined(HAVE_HANDLER_XATTR_GET)
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get_access(const struct xattr_handler *handler,
struct dentry *dentry, const char *name, void *buffer, size_t size)
{
int type = handler->flags;
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
return (zpl_xattr_acl_get(dentry->d_inode, name, buffer, size, type));
}
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get_default(const struct xattr_handler *handler,
struct dentry *dentry, const char *name, void *buffer, size_t size)
{
int type = handler->flags;
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
return (zpl_xattr_acl_get(dentry->d_inode, name, buffer, size, type));
}
#else
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get_access(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
void *buffer, size_t size)
{
return (zpl_xattr_acl_get(ip, name, buffer, size, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS));
}
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_get_default(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
void *buffer, size_t size)
{
return (zpl_xattr_acl_get(ip, name, buffer, size, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT));
}
#endif /* HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_GET */
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags, int type)
{
struct posix_acl *acl;
int error = 0;
if (strcmp(name, "") != 0)
return (-EINVAL);
if (ITOZSB(ip)->z_acl_type != ZFS_ACLTYPE_POSIXACL)
return (-EOPNOTSUPP);
if (!zpl_inode_owner_or_capable(ip))
return (-EPERM);
if (value) {
acl = zpl_acl_from_xattr(value, size);
if (IS_ERR(acl))
return (PTR_ERR(acl));
else if (acl) {
error = posix_acl_valid(acl);
if (error) {
zpl_posix_acl_release(acl);
return (error);
}
}
} else {
acl = NULL;
}
error = zpl_set_acl(ip, type, acl);
zpl_posix_acl_release(acl);
return (error);
}
#ifdef HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_SET
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set_access(struct dentry *dentry, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags, int type)
{
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
return (zpl_xattr_acl_set(dentry->d_inode,
name, value, size, flags, type));
}
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set_default(struct dentry *dentry, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags, int type)
{
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
return zpl_xattr_acl_set(dentry->d_inode,
name, value, size, flags, type);
}
#elif defined(HAVE_HANDLER_XATTR_SET)
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set_access(const struct xattr_handler *handler,
struct dentry *dentry, const char *name, const void *value, size_t size,
int flags)
{
int type = handler->flags;
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
return (zpl_xattr_acl_set(dentry->d_inode,
name, value, size, flags, type));
}
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set_default(const struct xattr_handler *handler,
struct dentry *dentry, const char *name, const void *value, size_t size,
int flags)
{
int type = handler->flags;
ASSERT3S(type, ==, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
return zpl_xattr_acl_set(dentry->d_inode,
name, value, size, flags, type);
}
#else
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set_access(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags)
{
return zpl_xattr_acl_set(ip,
name, value, size, flags, ACL_TYPE_ACCESS);
}
static int
zpl_xattr_acl_set_default(struct inode *ip, const char *name,
const void *value, size_t size, int flags)
{
return zpl_xattr_acl_set(ip,
name, value, size, flags, ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT);
}
#endif /* HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_SET */
struct xattr_handler zpl_xattr_acl_access_handler =
{
.prefix = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_ACCESS,
.list = zpl_xattr_acl_list_access,
.get = zpl_xattr_acl_get_access,
.set = zpl_xattr_acl_set_access,
#if defined(HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_LIST) || defined(HAVE_HANDLER_XATTR_LIST)
.flags = ACL_TYPE_ACCESS,
#endif /* HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_LIST */
};
struct xattr_handler zpl_xattr_acl_default_handler =
{
.prefix = POSIX_ACL_XATTR_DEFAULT,
.list = zpl_xattr_acl_list_default,
.get = zpl_xattr_acl_get_default,
.set = zpl_xattr_acl_set_default,
#if defined(HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_LIST) || defined(HAVE_HANDLER_XATTR_LIST)
.flags = ACL_TYPE_DEFAULT,
#endif /* HAVE_DENTRY_XATTR_LIST */
};
#endif /* CONFIG_FS_POSIX_ACL */
xattr_handler_t *zpl_xattr_handlers[] = {
&zpl_xattr_security_handler,
&zpl_xattr_trusted_handler,
&zpl_xattr_user_handler,
#ifdef CONFIG_FS_POSIX_ACL
&zpl_xattr_acl_access_handler,
&zpl_xattr_acl_default_handler,
#endif /* CONFIG_FS_POSIX_ACL */
NULL
};